Smucker's
Creamy Natural Peanut Butter
Made from one food: peanuts
Peanut Butter
CModerate GoutMarket grade · Moderate · #30 of 34 peanut butter we grade
Better-rated on this shelf
We earn a commission when you buy through paid links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never changes a rating or a ranking. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How we stay independent.
Check price at Amazon Paid link Check price at Walmart
Better-rated swaps
Same shelf, a better grade. Ranked by gout rating only.
Trader Joe's
Peanut Butter Creamy Unsalted
Made from one food: peanuts
Trader Joe's
Organic Creamy Peanut Butter Salted Valencia
Made from one food: peanuts
Purine and sugar, by the numbers
| Serving | 2 Tbsp (32 g) |
|---|---|
| Purine per serving | about 3 mg, at most 5 mg (1% of the 400 mg daily guide) |
| Purine per 100 g | at most 15 mg |
| Purine before GoutSafe's weighting | at most 16 mg per serving |
| Main purine source | peanuts |
| Fructose per serving | 1.5 g |
| Added sugar per serving | not on the label |
| Total sugar per serving | 3 g |
The weighted figure is lower than the one before weighting because GoutSafe counts purine from plants at a fraction of the same amount from meat or fish. The grade uses the weighted figure.
Where the purine comes from
| Ingredient | Matched GoutSafe food | Purine in that food, per 100 g | Share of the product | Purine at that share, per serving | Counted in the worst case |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| roasted peanuts | peanuts (A) | 49 mg | up to 100% | 16 mg | 5 mg |
| hydrogenated vegetable oil (cottonseed, soybean | dried soybeans (A) | 33 mg | up to 33% | 4 mg | under 1 mg |
Purine values come from each matched food's page on GoutSafe. Shares come from label order: US labels list ingredients by weight, so the second ingredient is at most half the product, and anything after "2% or less" is at most 2%. The worst case fills the most purine-dense ingredients to their full share first, until the shares reach the whole product, then applies GoutSafe's weighting by source, which counts plant purines at 0.3, dairy at 0 and organ meat at 1.3 because they raise uric acid by different amounts. The grade uses that worst case. How we rate.
Why it's rated C
- Open Food Facts classes it as ultra-processed (NOVA 4), and GoutSafe's rule keeps ultra-processed foods at Moderate (C) or below. Source on GoutSafe.
- About 3 mg of purine per serving, and at most 5 mg (1% of the 400 mg daily guide), mostly from peanuts. Source on GoutSafe.
- The panel lists 3 g of total sugars per serving and no added-sugar line.
Estimated from the ingredient label. Labels list ingredients by weight but rarely give amounts, so we grade on the most purine the label allows, which can read stricter than the real recipe and never safer. Sugar comes from the Nutrition Facts panel. How we rate.
What's on the label
Ingredients: ROASTED PEANUTS, SUGAR, HYDROGENATED VEGETABLE OIL (COTTONSEED, SOYBEAN AND RAPESEED OIL) TO PREVENT SEPARATION, SALT
Same recipe also sold as Creamy Peanut Butter, Extra crunchy peanut butter, Creamy peanut butter creamy. Serving: 2 Tbsp (32 g). Label from USDA FoodData Central (record 2674433), dated 2023-11-16. UPC 037600110754. This label is over a year old and the recipe may have changed. Check the package.
Where to buy
Check price at Amazon Paid link Check price at Walmart
Prices change often, so we don't show them. The rating is the same whichever store you pick.